Manuscript No.
A-

Reviewer No.
R-

Recommendation:
Publish as is.
Reject.
Reject as inappropriate for the role and scope of the journal.
Publish after revision


General Comments


Purpose/Methodology
Is the purpose clearly stated? Is the methodology appropriate to the purpose?

Arguments
Is there sufficient support for the argument or thesis of the paper?

Weaknesses
What areas need strengthening?

Revisions
Please explain, specifically, the revisions that must occur
before the paper is publishable.

If the paper is not appropriate for the journal, is there another journal
or genre of publication for which it might be appropriate?